Haven't read the paper, but while I don't believe
strongly in multiple hearts, I can imagine 2 ways around this problem: either
the intermediate stage were thick contractile neck arteries (IMHO this can
easily have been the final stage), or multiple real hearts appeared due to some
sort of Hox fluke. Whether the latter is possible is probably
testable.
I've got the opportunity to
read this interesting paper. It concerns only Giraffatitan brancai and
no other sauropods, about which it only includes cautionary notes about
diversity. It arrives at the conclusion that G. held its neck
vertically by measuring the areas of the intervertebral disks and calculating
stresses. Unlike the paper that concludes that all sauropod necks were
horizontal (ref later if needed), it considers the cervical ribs resistant
against tension -- so that the head didn't fall on the back -- rather than as
resistant against compression and providing the ventral bracing of a
beam.
Does this f happen to be a
Polish l with a / through it?
Air
sacs.
|